Advertiser disclosure: we may earn a commission.

How CardSherlock Works

Most credit card comparison sites show you today's offer and tell you it's great. CardSherlock does something different: it shows you where today's offer stands relative to every offer that card has run over the past 24 months, so you can decide whether now is actually the right time to apply.

What We Track

CardSherlock monitors credit cards across major U.S. issuers, including Chase, American Express, Capital One, Citi, Barclays, Bank of America, and Discover. For each card, we track:

  • Current sign-up bonus: the offer available today
  • 24-month bonus history: a monthly snapshot of every offer that card has run over the past two years
  • 24-month high and low: the best and worst offer recorded in our tracking window
  • Estimated value: a dollar-equivalent estimate of the bonus based on standard points/miles valuations
  • Verdict: our data-driven assessment of whether now is a good time to apply

We focus exclusively on sign-up bonuses. We do not track ongoing earning rates, perks, or benefits. There are plenty of sites that do that well. Our edge is timing data.

Our Methodology

Monthly snapshots, locked on the 1st

On the first day of each month, we record the publicly available sign-up bonus for every card in our database. This gives us a consistent, comparable data point each month, not a real-time scrape that fluctuates day to day.

Where the data comes from

We collect bonus data by monitoring each card's official issuer application page and cross-referencing with publicly reported offers. We do not rely on user-submitted data. When an issuer runs a limited-time elevated offer, we record the highest publicly available bonus at the time of the snapshot.

What counts as the "bonus"

We record the primary welcome offer: the points, miles, or cash back earned after meeting the spending requirement within the introductory period. We note the spending requirement and time window separately. We do not include referral bonuses, targeted offers, or in-branch-only offers unless they become broadly available.

Two-part offers

Some welcome offers come in two parts: miles plus Delta flight certificates, miles plus a statement credit, or Hilton points plus a Free Night Reward. We show both parts next to the bonus. The history, the highs and lows and the verdict compare only the main points, miles or cash figure, so the second part never moves a verdict. Our estimated value counts both parts, with the second part valued this way:

  • Statement credits at face value.
  • A free night certificate with a points cap at that cap times our cents-per-point value for the hotel program.
  • An uncapped Hilton Free Night Reward at a fixed $400.
  • A round-trip Delta flight certificate at a fixed $500 each.

On a card page, the written summary names only the main figure, so the value it quotes there is that figure's share; the estimated value shown with the offer counts both parts.

How Verdicts Are Calculated

Each card receives one of four verdicts, updated monthly when new data is locked:

  • 🔥 Peak Offer: The current bonus equals or exceeds the 24-month high. This is as good as it gets in our tracking window. Strong signal to apply now.
  • ↑ Above Typical: The current bonus is above the 24-month median but below the all-time high. A solid offer, worth applying for unless you have reason to believe a peak is imminent.
  • → Typical: The current bonus is in line with what this card typically offers. Not a bad offer, but not exceptional. Apply based on your personal need for the card, not urgency.
  • ⏳ Below Typical / Wait: The current bonus is below the 24-month median. Historical data suggests better offers have run and may run again. Wait and monitor.

Verdicts are calculated automatically from the historical data: there is no editorial judgment applied to individual card scores.

What We Don't Know (And Won't Pretend To)

Our data window is 24 months. A card with an unusually elevated offer 25 months ago would not affect today's verdict. We cannot predict when issuers will run elevated offers; we can only tell you where you stand relative to recent history.

CardSherlock is not a financial advisor. We don't know your credit score, spending habits, or travel goals. Our verdicts are a data signal, not a personal recommendation. Use them as one input in your decision, alongside your own research.

Editorial Independence

CardSherlock earns affiliate commissions when you apply for cards through our links. Our verdicts are not influenced by affiliate relationships. A card with a below-typical bonus gets a "Wait" verdict regardless of how much commission it might generate. We built this tool because we wanted accurate timing data for ourselves. That motivation doesn't change because there's a commission attached.

If you have questions about our methodology or spot a data discrepancy, contact us at hello@cardsherlock.com.

Last updated: May 2026

Ready to find your best card?
Browse every tracked card with live bonus data, history charts, and Sherlock's Verdict on every offer.
Browse the Card Table →